Friday, April 26, 2013

Final Revisions

As you gear up for the final revision of your essay of choice, remember the advice that I gave you in class this week when choosing which essay to revise: pick the essay that has the most potential, not necessarily the essay that received the best grade OR the one you "liked" the best.

Make sure you approach your revisions logically (recalling that your efforts account for 33% of your final grade), focusing on the global revisions first and the sentence-level revisions last.  Your Bedford Handbook provides these suggestions when making global revisions (2b & 2c):

Revision Guidelines

Global Revisions
Sentence-level Revisions
SHARPENING THE FOCUS (Purpose)
Look for opportunities
  • to clarify the introduction (especially the thesis)
  • to delete text that is off the point
IMPROVING THE ORGANIZATION
Look for opportunities
  • to add or sharpen topic sentences
  • to move blocks of text
  • to reparagraph and perhaps to add headings
STRENGTHENING THE CONTENT (Development)
Look for opportunities
  • to add specific facts, details, and examples
  • to emphasize major ideas
  • to rethink your argument or central insight
CLARIFYING THE POINT OF VIEW  (Language)
Look for opportunities
  • to make the point of view more consistent
  • to use a more appropriate point of view
ENGAGING THE AUDIENCE (Language)
Look for opportunities
  • to let readers know why they are reading
  • to motivate readers to read on
  • to use a more appropriate tone
STRENGTHENING SENTENCES (Usage)
Look for opportunities
  • to use more active verbs
  • to prune excess words
CLARIFYING SENTENCES (Usage)
Look for opportunities
  • to balance parallel ideas
  • to supply missing words
  • to untangle mixed constructions
  • to repair misplaced or dangling modifiers
  • to eliminate distracting shifts
INTRODUCING VARIETY (Language)
Look for opportunities
  • to combine choppy sentences
  • to break up long sentences
  • to vary sentence openings
REFINING THE STYLE (Language)
Look for opportunities
  • to choose language more appropriate for the subject
  • and audience
  • to choose more exact words

Revision Checklist
Global Revisions
Sentence-level Revisions (Usage)
FOCUS (Purpose)
  • Does the introduction focus on the main point?
  • Is the thesis clear enough? (If there is no thesis, is there a good reason for omitting one?)
  • Are any ideas off the point?
ORGANIZATION
  • Does the writer give readers enough organizational cues (such as topic sentences or headings)?
  • Should any text be moved?
  • Are any paragraphs too long or short for easy reading?
CONTENT (Development)
  • Are there enough facts, examples, and details to support major ideas?
  • Are the parts proportioned sensibly? Do major ideas receive enough attention?
  • How might the argument be strengthened?
POINT OF VIEW (Language)
  • Is the draft free of distracting shifts in point of view?
  • Is the point appropriate?
AUDIENCE APPEAL (Language)
  • Does the draft accomplish its purpose to inform us, to persuade us, to entertain us, to call us to action (or some combination of these)?
  • Does the opening paragraph make us want to read on? Do we know why we are reading?
  • Is the tone appropriate?
GRAMMAR
  • Sentence fragments
  • Run-on sentences
  • Subject-verb agreement
  • Pronoun-antecedent agreement
  • Pronoun reference
  • Case of nouns and pronouns
  • Case of
  • who
  • and
  • whom
  • Adjectives and adverbs
  • Standard English verb forms
  • Verb tense, mood, and voice
  • ESL problems
PUNCTUATION
  • The comma and unnecessary commas
  • Quotation marks
  • End punctuation
  • The semicolon
  • The colon
  • The apostrophe
  • Other punctuation marks
MECHANICS
  • Abbreviations and numbers
  • Italics (underlining)
  • Spelling and the hyphen
  • Capital letters 

No comments: